Why Does Your Mattress Not Feel Like It Did In The Store?

Have you ever purchased a new mattress, only to find that it doesn’t feel quite the same as it did in the store?

It’s a common complaint among mattress buyers, and one that can be frustrating to deal with.

In this article, we’ll explore some of the reasons why your mattress may not feel the same as it did in the store and offer tips on how to improve your sleep comfort.

  • Mattress comfort is subjective and varies from person to person.
  • Factors such as room temperature, humidity, and the type of foundation or bed frame you’re using can affect the feel of your mattress.
  • To replicate the store comfort at home, try to recreate the same conditions as the store, such as using the same bed frame and bedding, and giving the mattress time to break in.

EIGHT Reasons Why Your Mattress Feels Different At Home

When you first try out a new mattress in the store, it can feel like the most comfortable thing in the world. But when you get it home, it may not feel quite the same.

Understanding the factors that contribute to mattress comfort can help you choose a mattress that will feel just as good at home as it did in the store.

1. Mattress Firmness

One of the most important factors that affects mattress comfort is firmness. Mattresses can range from very soft to very firm, and the right level of firmness for you will depend on your personal preferences and sleeping position.

As a general rule, back and stomach sleepers tend to prefer firmer mattresses, while side sleepers may prefer something softer.

2. Mattress Construction

The construction of a mattress can also affect its comfort. Most mattresses are made up of several layers, including a support core, comfort layers, and a mattress cover.

The materials used in each of these layers can affect how the mattress feels. For example, thicker comfort layers made of more conforming materials tend to give the mattress a softer feel, while thinner layers made of less malleable materials contribute to a firmer surface.

3. Mattress Comfort Layers

The comfort layers of a mattress are located at the top of the mattress and are designed to provide cushioning and support.

These layers can be made from a variety of materials, including memory foam, latex, and polyfoam.

Each of these materials has its own unique feel and can affect how the mattress contours to your body.

4. Break-In Period

It’s important to keep in mind that new mattresses may feel different than they did in the store due to a break-in period. As you sleep on your new mattress, it will start to conform to your body and soften up.

This can take anywhere from a few days to a few weeks, depending on the materials used in the mattress.

5. Pillow Influence

Your pillow can also play a role in how your mattress feels. A thicker, fluffier pillow can make your mattress feel softer, while a thinner pillow can make it feel firmer.

Additionally, the material of your pillow can impact the feel of your mattress. For example, a memory foam pillow may provide more support and make your mattress feel firmer, while a down pillow may make it feel softer.

6. Bed Frame Impact

Believe it or not, your bed frame can also affect how your mattress feels. A sturdy, supportive bed frame can help your mattress feel firmer, while a slatted bed frame may make it feel softer.

Additionally, the height of your bed frame can impact the feel of your mattress. A higher bed frame can make your mattress feel softer, while a lower bed frame can make it feel firmer.

7. Environment

Another reason why your new mattress may feel different is that your sleeping environment at home is different from the store. The temperature, humidity, and lighting in the store may be different from your bedroom.

Additionally, the store may have a different type of flooring than your home, which can affect the way the mattress feels.

8. Body Impressions

Over time, your body will leave impressions on the mattress. This is known as body impressions and is not the same as mattress sag.

As you sleep on the mattress, the foam layers will relax and mold to your body shape. This can cause the mattress to feel different over time.

FIVE Tips to Replicate Store Comfort at Home

When you first got your new mattress, it probably felt like sleeping on a cloud. But now, it doesn’t feel as comfortable as it did in the store. Don’t worry, there are a few things you can do to replicate that store comfort at home.

1. Use a Mattress Cover

One of the easiest ways to make your mattress feel more comfortable is to use a mattress cover. A mattress cover can help protect your mattress from spills, stains, and allergens, but it can also add an extra layer of cushioning. Look for a mattress cover that is made from a soft, breathable material like cotton or bamboo.

2. Invest in a Good Pillow

Your pillow can also have a big impact on how comfortable your mattress feels. Make sure you’re using a pillow that supports your head and neck in a neutral position. If your pillow is too flat or too firm, it can cause discomfort and pain. Look for a pillow that is made from a breathable material like down or memory foam.

3. Check Your Bed Frame

Believe it or not, your bed frame can also affect how comfortable your mattress feels. Make sure your bed frame is sturdy and supportive. If your bed frame is old or worn out, it can cause your mattress to sag or feel lumpy. Consider investing in a new bed frame if yours is no longer providing the support you need.

4. Give Your Mattress Time to Break In

It’s also important to remember that new mattresses can take some time to break in. The materials in your mattress need time to adjust to your body and sleeping habits. Give your mattress at least a few weeks to break in before deciding if it’s not comfortable enough.

5. Consider Adding a Mattress Topper

If your mattress still isn’t as comfortable as you’d like, consider adding a mattress topper. A mattress topper is an extra layer of cushioning that can help make your mattress feel softer and more comfortable.

Look for a mattress topper that is made from a material that suits your sleeping preferences, such as memory foam or latex.


Overall, it is important to understand that your new mattress may not feel exactly like the one in the store, but with proper care and patience, you can still enjoy a comfortable and restful sleep.

Additional Bed Topics
Is It Safe to Sleep on a Broken Bed Frame?
Why Are Bed Frames So Expensive?
Why Is Bedding So Expensive?
Is It Worth Upgrading to a King Size Bed?
Do You Need to Clean Under Your Bed?
Can a Bed Be Too Comfortable?
What Can You Do If You Hate Your New Bed?
Why Is Your Bed Always So Cold at Night?
Can You Put Bed Sheets with Vomit in the Washing Machine?
Should You Put a Bed in the Nursery (for Parents)?
Does It Make Sense for a Child to Have a King Size Bed?
Is It Bad To Place A Bed Over A Floor Vent?
Should A Single Person Get a King Size Bed?
Should You Put A Rug Under Your Bed?
How Much Should You Spend On A Bed Frame?
Do Mattresses Get Heavier Over Time?
Can You Put A Bed In Front Of A Window Or Wall Vent?
Is It Bad to Put Your Bed in A Corner?
Why Do You Feel Something Moving Inside Your Mattress?
Why Does Your Bed Always Feel Sandy?
Why Does Your Bed ALWAYS Feel Damp?
Why Does Your Mattress Not Feel Like It Did In The Store?
Should Spare Beds Be Made Up?
Does a Bed Need Two Nightstands?
Is a Queen Bed Too Big for Your Toddler?
Can You Use a Single Electric Blanket on a Double Bed?
Can You Plug Something in Behind Your Bed?
Is it Safe to Have a Power Strip on Your Bed?